Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Murphy column: Governor’s faith isn’t rewarded

Murphy column: Governor’s faith isn’t rewarded

  • 0
Virus Outbreak Iowa

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds updates the state’s response to the coronavirus outbreak during a news conference on Sept. 29 in Johnston.

It’s one thing to express the optimistic or hopeful view when attempting to lead a state through a global pandemic.

It’s another thing to make a statement that plainly defies the evidence literally right in front of you.

The least plausible line delivered during President Donald Trump’s rally this past week in Iowa may have actually come from Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds. Reynolds was addressing the crowd at the Des Moines airport during the event’s warm-up speeches before Trump arrived, when she said she was proud to be the type of governor that trusts her constituents to be responsible and do the right thing.

This comment was made to a crowd of thousands who were packed together, with few people wearing face coverings. Those actions are contrary to the advice of public health and infectious disease experts, and they happened in a state where COVID-related hospitalizations are at their highest point of the pandemic and still climbing.

“I am proud to be a governor that puts trust in her people because they are responsible, they are resilient, and they will do the right thing,” Reynolds yelled into the sea of closely gathered, mostly mask-less faces.

The whole event ran afoul of Reynolds’ own state proclamation that public gatherings must include social distancing. It’s safe to say the thousands who attended the rally were not standing 6 feet apart. The one thing that mitigated the potential public health danger was that the event was held outside, where the virus does not spread as easily.

It is understandable that part of a governor’s job is to be the state’s cheerleader, and to that end Reynolds may have opted for a more positive, encouraging tone on face mask use during the pandemic. She may believe encouraging people to wear masks in public is more effective than scolding or punishing people who do not. And she may believe it is more effective to suggest most Iowans are wearing face masks in public, even if that’s not true.

However, it was a serious stretch when Reynolds stood on that stage, looked at that crowd, and suggested Iowans “will do the right thing” when hundreds, standing directly in front of her, were not.

This past week, COVID-related hospitalizations set new record after new record in Iowa, with 468 Iowans hospitalized as of Friday afternoon. Recent COVID-19 hospital admissions also continued to soar to new highs, averaging nearly 70 over the most recent 10 days.

COVID-19-related deaths also continue to climb in Iowa: the 14-day average of new deaths reported daily was at its highest since early June, when death numbers were coming down from their first peak.

According to public health and infectious disease experts, one of the best ways to help slow the spread of the virus is to wear face masks when near other people in public.

That, in terms of public health, is doing the right thing.

— Erin Murphy covers Iowa politics and government for Lee Enterprises. His email address is Follow him on Twitter at @ErinDMurphy.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert